Product
PricingResources
Try a RoleplaySign In
  1. Home
  2. Blogs
  3. How to Review Sales Calls (With a Checklist)
How to review sales calls header
Blogs

How to Review Sales Calls (With a Checklist)

Jay Shah avatarBy Jay Shah·Updated: 11/16/2026·14 min read
Share:
On this page

Quick answer:

  • Don’t listen start to finish. Know what the call had to achieve, skim the transcript, then jump to the opening, the first pain, the first objection and the last five minutes.
  • Check six things: opening, discovery depth, talk time, longest monologue, objection handling and the next step. Put a timestamp on every note.
  • Ask the rep what they’d redo, give one piece of feedback, agree on one practice rep, and check that same thing next week.

Rafael never learned how to review sales calls, so on Wednesday he does it the thorough way. He plays a 45-minute discovery call his rep Imani ran on Monday, start to finish, and writes 14 notes: slow down, fewer “ums,” ask who signs, and eleven more. Imani replies “thanks, super useful” and runs her Thursday call exactly the same way.

None of the notes were wrong. But there were 14, none pointed to a moment Imani could go back and hear, and nothing told her what to do differently. This guide covers which calls to pick, a 15-minute review, a checklist, a template, a sample and how to give the feedback.

What is a sales call review?

A sales call review is going back over a recorded call to find the moments that helped or hurt the deal, then turning them into one specific change for the rep’s next call. When a team does it together on a shared clip, it’s usually called a game tape review. It’s different from a deal review, which asks whether the deal will close.

Which sales calls should you review?

Review the calls most likely to teach you something: lost or stalled deals, a new rep’s early calls, calls with outlier numbers, and a win for every loss.

  1. Lost or stalled deals, at the stage where they died. If a deal went quiet after the second call, review the second call.
  2. A new rep’s early calls. In the Bridge Group’s 2025 report, SDR ramp time was 3.0 months, so a new rep’s first few weeks of calls are a big share of their ramp.
  3. Outlier calls. No next step booked, rep talk time over 65%, or a 45-minute slot that ended at minute 12.
  4. One win for every loss. Otherwise you only learn what failure sounds like, and the rep only hears criticism.

For the weekly system around this, see our guide on how to coach sales reps.

How to review sales calls in 15 minutes

You can review a 45-minute call in about 15 minutes: two minutes of prep, a skim of the transcript, then four key moments at 1.5x speed, each with a timestamped note. Then pick one thing.

  1. Before you press play, know the stage and the goal (2 minutes). A discovery call might need to confirm the problem, put a cost on it, find who else decides and book a demo. Write that at the top. You’re judging the call against its job, not against a perfect call.
  2. Skim the transcript or summary (2 minutes). Search for “price,” “budget,” “next” and “competitor” to find the turning points.
  3. Jump to the key moments (8 minutes):
    – The opening (first 3 minutes): was there an agenda, and did the rep ask what the buyer wanted from the call?
    – The first pain: did the rep dig in or move on?
    – The first objection: what did the rep say in the 30 seconds after it?
    – The last 5 minutes: what exactly was agreed?
  4. Listen at 1.5x, and slow to 1x for objections. Tone matters there.
  5. Timestamp every note as mm:ss plus what was said. Write “24:10: buyer said it sounded expensive, rep offered the annual discount right away,” not “weak on price.” The rep can go hear it.
  6. Pick one thing (1 minute). Which moment cost the most against the goal you wrote down? That’s your feedback.

What’s on a sales call review checklist?

A sales call review checklist covers six areas: the opening, discovery depth, talk time, the longest monologue, objection handling and the next step.

If you’ve seen the “7 steps of a sales call” (preparation, opening, discovery, presentation, objections, close, follow-up), they fold into these six. Prep and follow-up happen off the call.

Area What to check What good sounds like Data point
Opening and agenda Time, purpose and what the buyer wants to cover “We have 45 minutes. I’d like to hear how you handle orders today. What do you want to cover?” It happened or it didn’t.
Discovery depth Follow-ups on surface answers “You said re-entering orders eats the morning. How many hours a week is that?” In Gong’s 2025 data, reps asked 15 to 16 questions on won deals and about 20 per call on lost ones.
Talk time This call vs the rep’s own wins Close to the rep’s usual on won deals Gong’s 2025 refresh of 326K calls: 57% rep talk time on won deals, 62% on lost.
Longest monologue Did the buyer ask for it? A long answer the buyer requested, then a check-in Gong (2025): “Lost deals often feature long seller monologues.”
Objection handling A question before an answer “Fair. More than you expected, or more than you’ve set aside?” In Gong’s 2021 data, top reps answered objections with questions 54.3% of the time vs 31% for average reps.
Next step Specific, dated, agreed by the buyer “Thursday at 2 with your ops director. Does that work?” Gong’s 2021 study of 8,382 deals: 20% close rate with next steps discussed vs 5% without.

Treat talk time as a symptom, not a target. The famous 43:57 “golden ratio” is Gong’s 2016 benchmark. Gong’s 2025 update on the same page puts won deals at 57% rep talk time. A rep at 58% isn’t broken. When a rep who usually sits in the mid 50s hits 70%, something else went wrong first.

Check follow-ups, not question counts. Reps on lost deals asked more questions in that 2025 data, not fewer. Past a point, more questions is a list being read out loud.

Monologues depend on the call. On cold calls, Gong’s 2021 data found successful calls had a longer average monologue (53 seconds vs 25). What hurts is a long answer nobody asked for, followed by shorter buyer replies.

For a weighted version, see our sales call scorecard template. For follow-ups to borrow, try our discovery call questions.

Sales call review template

Copy this and fill it in as you listen. Score each area 1 to 3: 1 means missed, 2 means partly or late, 3 means done clearly.

SALES CALL REVIEW
Rep:                       Reviewer:
Date of call:              Length:
Deal:                      Stage:
Goal of this call (one sentence):

SCORES (1 = missed, 2 = partly, 3 = clearly)
Opening and agenda:   _
Discovery depth:      _
Talk time:            _  (this call __%, rep's usual on wins __%)
Longest monologue:    _  (length ____ at mm:ss)
Objection handling:   _
Next step:            _  (what, when, buyer agreed? y/n)

KEY MOMENTS (mm:ss, what was said, what happened next)

WHAT WORKED (aim for 3, each with a timestamp)

THE ONE THING (one behavior, one timestamp)

PRACTICE REP FOR NEXT WEEK
What, how many times, and how we'll check it on real calls:

PARKED FOR LATER (noticed, not raised this week)

The “parked for later” line gives your other 13 notes somewhere to go besides the rep’s inbox.

Sample sales call review

Here’s Rafael’s review of Imani’s call, done the 15-minute way.

Rep: Imani        Reviewer: Rafael       Length: 45:12
Deal: 40-seat logistics team, inbound     Stage: Discovery
Goal: confirm the order-entry problem and its cost, find who
else decides, book a demo with that person.

SCORES
Opening 3 | Discovery 2 | Talk time 2 (63% vs her usual 54%)
Monologue 1 (3:40 at 17:30) | Objections 1 | Next step 1

KEY MOMENTS
00:40  Set the agenda, asked what the buyer wanted to cover.
06:45  Buyer: "Our dispatchers spend half the morning
       re-entering orders." Imani: "How many hours a week is
       that?" Buyer: about 30.
17:30  3:40 product overview nobody asked for. Buyer's
       answers get shorter after this.
24:10  Buyer: "This sounds expensive for a team our size."
       Imani gave the price range and the annual discount
       within 10 seconds. Buyer: "OK, I'll think about it."
41:50  "I'll send over some info and we can reconnect."
       No date, no word on who else decides.

WHAT WORKED
00:40  Asking what he wanted to cover surfaced pricing early.
06:45  Put a number on the pain (30 hours a week).
12:20  Played the problem back in the buyer's words.

THE ONE THING
24:10  Ask a question before giving any number. The call
turned here.

PRACTICE REP
Run the "too expensive for a team our size" moment 3 times
before Thursday, opening with: "Expensive compared to what
you expected, or to what re-entering orders costs you now?"
Check: objection score on her next 3 discovery calls.

PARKED FOR LATER
17:30 monologue. 41:50 next step with no date.

The “ums” and the monologue are parked. Imani gets one change to practice before Thursday.

How do you give feedback on a sales call?

Let the rep review first, then give one piece of timestamped feedback, framed as situation, behavior and impact, with about three positives per critical note. End with a practice rep you check next week.

Feedback isn’t automatically helpful. In a 1996 meta-analysis by Kluger and DeNisi (607 effect sizes, 23,663 observations), feedback improved performance on average, but over a third of feedback interventions decreased performance. Feedback that pulls attention to the person (“you rushed”) instead of the task (“at 24:10, the price came before a question”) is the risky kind.

  1. The rep goes first. Send the recording a day ahead and ask “What would you redo?” and “What did the buyer say they need next?” When the rep finds the same moment you did, you’re agreeing instead of correcting.
  2. Use SBI, plus intent. The Center for Creative Leadership’s SBI model names the Situation, the observable Behavior and the Impact. CCL’s extended version adds Intent: “What were you hoping to accomplish with that?” For Imani: “At 24:10, when he said it sounded expensive, you gave the discount right away, and his answers got shorter. What were you going for?”
  3. One behavior per review. Raise the moment that cost the most and leave the rest parked.
  4. About three positives to one critical. In Gong’s 2017 analysis of 5,000+ users, effective coaches left roughly three positive comments on call recordings for every critical one. Give positives timestamps too.
  5. Agree on a practice rep. The rep runs the moment again before the next call, with you or alone. Our objection handling roleplays include scripts for price.
  6. Check the same thing next week. Score only that area on the rep’s next two or three calls of the same type. In the CSO Insights 2019 Sales Enablement Study (900+ participants), teams with a “dynamic” coaching approach had a 55.2% win rate vs 41.8% for “random” coaching.

How do you run a game tape session with the team?

Run it weekly for 30 to 45 minutes around one clip, one question and one behavior.

  1. Context (5 minutes). The rep whose call it is explains the deal, the stage and the call’s goal.
  2. Play the clip (10 minutes). One 5 to 10 minute clip, played once without commentary.
  3. One question (15 minutes). For example, “What should she have asked at 06:50?”
  4. Try it live (10 minutes). Two reps run the moment out loud, one playing the buyer.
  5. Agree one behavior (5 minutes) that everyone tries this week.

Rotate whose clip it is, and bring wins too. For 30 minutes, skip the live run. Jeff Shore’s piece on reviewing game film describes a similar format.

How do you keep your scoring fair?

Calibrate with a second scorer. Buckingham and Goodall wrote in HBR in 2019 that “more than 50% of your rating of someone reflects your characteristics, not hers,” so check your scores against someone else’s.

  • Two managers score the same call each quarter, separately, using the template. Anywhere you’re two points apart needs a clearer “what good sounds like” line.
  • Score what was said, not how it felt. A quote and a timestamp are hard to argue with. “Felt rushed” isn’t.
  • Use each rep’s own wins as the baseline for talk time and monologues.

How does TrackPoint review sales calls?

TrackPoint is an AI sales training platform. It reviews your team’s calls, then trains each rep on the gaps it hears.

A sales call scored in TrackPoint, with talk ratio, pace and filler words
  • Every call scored on your scorecard. A notetaker picks up meetings from each rep’s Google or Outlook calendar and joins on Zoom, Google Meet or Microsoft Teams. Recordings can be uploaded too.
  • The numbers from this checklist, already counted. Talk-to-listen ratio, speaking pace and filler words come with every call, along with what went well and what to improve, so you know which moments are worth hearing.
  • A team view of every rep’s scores, so outlier calls stand out.
  • Weak moments become practice. A missed moment becomes an AI roleplay assigned to that rep, so the “practice rep” line in your template happens automatically.
  • Recaps sent for you. After each call, a summary with next steps lands in the inbox of everyone on the invite.

We never use your call data to train AI models (security). See how TrackPoint reviews calls, or run a free roleplay without signing up.

Frequently asked questions

What should you listen for when reviewing a sales call?

Listen for the agenda, discovery depth, talk time against the rep’s own wins, the longest monologue, how objections were answered, and whether the call ended with a dated next step the buyer agreed to. You rarely need the whole call to hear them.

What is a good talk-to-listen ratio on a sales call?

In Gong’s 2025 analysis of 326K sales calls, reps talked 57% of the time on won deals and 62% on lost deals. The often-quoted 43:57 ratio is Gong’s 2016 benchmark. Compare each rep with their own wins.

What questions should you ask a rep after a sales call?

Ask “What would you redo?” and “What did the buyer say they need next?” Then, about the moment you want to discuss, ask “What were you hoping to accomplish with that?” so you hear the rep’s intent before giving your view.

How do you give feedback on a sales call without demotivating the rep?

Keep it on one timestamped moment, not on the person. Give about three specific positives per critical note, as effective coaches did in Gong’s 2017 data. End with a practice rep, so the rep leaves with something to do.

Should reps review their own sales calls?

Yes, before the manager does. A rep who answers “What would you redo?” first usually spots the same moment, which turns feedback into agreement. On bigger teams, reps can nominate a 3-minute clip for the manager.

What is game tape in sales?

Game tape (or game film) is reviewing recorded sales calls the way sports teams review recorded games. The team plays a short clip, discusses one question, practices the moment out loud and agrees on one behavior to try that week.

Can AI review sales calls?

Yes. AI can transcribe a call, score it against your scorecard and point you to the timestamps worth hearing. A manager still decides what matters and has the feedback conversation. TrackPoint also turns weak moments into roleplays the rep practices before the next call.

What is the best way to track sales calls?

Record every call with a notetaker, score each one against the same scorecard, and keep scores per rep over time to see whether a behavior is changing. A tool like TrackPoint records and scores automatically, so nobody maintains a spreadsheet.

What should you do with the next call you review?

Pick one lost or stalled deal from this week, copy the template and give yourself 15 minutes. Write the goal at the top, jump to the four moments, and send the rep one timestamped change plus three things that worked.

Talk to our team to see your own calls scored on your scorecard without anyone pressing play, or try a free roleplay and practice the moment your last call went sideways.

Enjoyed this article? Share it with others!

Share:
Jay Shah avatar

Written by

Jay Shah

Founder, TrackPoint

Jay Shah is the founder of TrackPoint.ai, an AI practice platform for team training. He writes about learning and development, and building real skills through deliberate practice instead of passive content.

Try a Roleplay

No signup, and only takes 2 minutes.

Try the demo

Talk to Our Team

See TrackPoint on your own scenarios. We reply within one business day.

Related Resources

AI Sales Onboarding: A Guide to Faster Rep Ramp

AI Sales Onboarding: A Guide to Faster Rep Ramp

Blogs
New reps take longer than ever to ramp, and most onboarding makes it worse. Here’s how to onboard sales hires with practice, not another content dump.
Jay Shah avatarJay Shah· 06/06/2026
AI Sales Training: Why ChatGPT Is Not Enough

AI Sales Training: Why ChatGPT Is Not Enough

Blogs
ChatGPT can draft the email, but it can’t make your reps better at selling. Here’s why generic AI falls short and what actually builds rep skill.
Jay Shah avatarJay Shah· 01/22/2026
Introducing Semantic Reasoning: AI that keeps info out of it’s context
News

Introducing Semantic Reasoning: AI that keeps info out of it’s context

The race in AI has been to give models more to remember. Semantic Reasoning teaches them what to keep to themselves.
Jay Shah avatarJay Shah· 09/29/2026
← Back to All Posts

See how AI roleplays can transform your team's performance.

Transform your team's performance.

Try a RoleplayBook a Demo

Train your Team with AI Roleplays.

Platform

  • Product
  • Security
  • Pricing
  • FAQs

Use Cases

  • Learning & Development
  • Sales
  • Customer Support
  • Human Resources

Industries

  • Technology
  • Healthcare
  • Financial Services
  • Training Agencies
  • Education

Company

  • About
  • Resources
  • Careers
  • Tech Social
  • Contact

© 2026 TrackPoint Technologies Inc. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceCopyrightUsage Policy